Barack Obama swept into office promising
to change how Washington works. He swore that
the stimulus bill would have no earmarks and no "pork". But the
bill so laden with pork, so completely unhelpful to the economy, and so
inefficient on a cost benefit basis, that it makes you scratch your head.
Is this really what President Obama wants to spend his political capital
on - a non-stimulus "stimulus" bill? Is this really the best
the new Democrat administration can do?
In total, the bill spends $825B to create
or save 3.7M jobs. That means
the government will spend $222,972 per job. In contrast,
in 2007, the private sector created jobs at a cost of about $50,000 each.
As in most ventures, the government is woefully inefficient.
There are 152 separate appropriations in
the bill, but just 34 are related to creating or saving jobs.
Examples of appropriations that have
nothing to do with creating or saving jobs or otherwise stimulating the
economy:
- $50M for National Endowment for the Arts
- $300M for family planning services and
contraception
- $4.19B for ACORN
- $200B transfer payment to states
- $650M for digital TV coupons
Examples of appropriations that are not crucial to stimulating the
economy - just extra spending on "stuff" that should be part of a
normal budgeting cycle:
- $650M to repair Forest Service facilities
- $200M to spruce up the National Mall
- $276M to fix the computer systems at the State
Department
- $400M for Social Security Administration computer
systems
- $209M for facilities maintenance for the
Agricultural Research Service
- $600M for the General Services Administration to
buy new alternative-fuel cars and trucks
Of the 152 separate appropriations in the bill, just 11 generate
over half the estimated jobs at a cost of just $65B:
1. Highway Infrastructure Investment (835,000
jobs, $35,928 each) $30B
2. Clean Water State Revolving Fund (282,000
jobs, $21,276 each) $6B
3. Transit Capital Assistance (165,000 jobs,
$36,363 each) $6B
4. Child Care Development Block Grant
(125,000 jobs, $16,000 each) $2B
5. Weatherization Assistance (104,000 jobs,
$59,615 each) $6.2B
6. Drinking Water State Revolving Fund
(94,000 jobs, $21,276 each) $2B
7. Grants-in-Aid for Airports (75,000 jobs,
$40,000 each) $3B
8. Head Start (50,000 jobs, $42,000 each)
$2.1B
9. State Energy Program (41,000 jobs, $82,926
each) $3.4B
10. Energy Efficiency & Conservation
Grants (40,800 jobs, $85,784 each) $3.5B
11. Capital
Investment Grants (35,000 jobs, $28,571 each) $1B